guess it depends mainly on how often whispers are used these days, With both of us kind of on hiatus I’d guess we both really lack the knowledge.
If there are few to no whispers most days, my methods are better, if 2+ whispers are done yours are better. my fear is a bit less on practicality (Personally in my view in both of our concepts whispers are going to effectively have the same result, as a whisper jammer, however IMO the impersonate part will just result in complaints that that is worthless as some players will focus on it and miss the jam).
Biggest difference in our styles, I’m more paranoid of negative feedback rolling things back because of complaints. I see a whole lot of potential as a whisper jammer, and effectively no potential as a whisper spoofer unless whispering becomes far more flooded. I’m more afraid of people seeing the spoofer and not seeing the jammer part of it.